69 UNDERHILL Avenue Unit MIXED_USE, Brooklyn, NY 11238

$3,000,000

Introducing 67-69 Underhill Avenue, a fully free-market, corner mixed-use property package located in an iconic section of Prospect Heights, ideally positioned between Bergen Street and Saint Marks Avenue. This rare offering comprises two adjoining mixed-use buildings situated on a prominent corner, providing strong street presence, operational flexibility, and long-term… Read More value in one of Brooklyn's most established and supply-constrained neighborhoods. The property spans a combined 50.42 ft 78 ft lot and is situated within R6B zoning, offering approximately 897 square feet of unused FAR, presenting clear upside through future reconfiguration, enhancement, or expansion, subject to approvals. Each building features a commercial space at grade with two residential units above, totaling four residential apartments across the assemblage. All residential units are configured as three-bedroom, one-bath layouts, a consistently in-demand unit type within the Prospect Heights rental market. Further enhancing the asset's versatility is an auto body shop with an existing curb cut located off Bergen Street, providing an additional income stream and operational flexibility. The entire property is fully free-market, positioning ownership to unlock value through strategic leasing, repositioning, or a long-term hold strategy. The location is a defining attribute. Situated in the heart of Prospect Heights, 67-69 Underhill Avenue is just a short stroll from Prospect Park and Grand Army Plaza, and moments from Barclays Center, one of Brooklyn's premier sports and entertainment destinations. The property also benefits from a short jaunt to Atlantic Terminal, offering access to multiple additional subway lines as well as the Long Island Rail Road (LIRR), providing exceptional regional connectivity. Transit options nearby include the C train at Clinton-Washington Avenues, the A, C, and S lines, and the 2 and 3 trains at Grand Army Plaza, allowing for efficient travel throughout Brooklyn and Manhattan. Surrounded by Prospect Heights' most notable cultural and lifestyle amenities, the property is in close proximity to the Brooklyn Museum, Brooklyn Botanic Garden, and Brooklyn Public Library. The nearby retail corridors of Vanderbilt Avenue and Washington Avenue serve as major neighborhood arteries, offering a dense concentration of acclaimed restaurants, cafés, neighborhood markets, supermarkets, and everyday conveniences that continue to drive sustained tenant demand and long-term neighborhood growth. Whether an investor seeking durable income with meaningful upside or an owner-operator or end user pursuing a 1031 exchange, 67-69 Underhill Avenue represents a rare corner mixed-use opportunity in an iconic part of Brooklyn, combining scale, zoning flexibility, transit access, and enduring Prospect Heights appeal. Read Less

Listing Courtesy of: Jason Abrishami, Douglas Elliman Real Estate

Listing Snapshot

Days Online

Last Updated

Jan 14, 2026

Property Type

Apartment

Beds

Full Baths

Year Built

1931

MLS Number

RLS20066479

30 Days Snapshot Of 11238

$1.73M

+31%

(avg) sold price

-71%

homes sold

Snapshot

Area Map

Additional Details

Building

Entry Level: 1, Living Area Units: SquareFeet, Rooms Total: 13

Exterior Features

Patio And Porch Features: None

Lot

Parcel Number: 01146-0011

Property

Property Sub Type: Apartment

Taxes

Tax Block: 01146, Tax Lot: 0011

Find The Perfect Home

'VIP' Listing Search

Whenever a listing hits the market that matches your criteria you will be immediately notified.

Join The List

Mortgage Calculator

Selling price

Down payment

Term (years)

Interest rate (%)

Monthly Payment

Manhattan

Brooklyn

69 UNDERHILL Avenue Unit MIXED_USE

'VIP' Listing Search

Schools In The Area

Similar Listings

Find My Dream Home

1. Neighborhoods

2. Home Type

3. Send

Become an Insider